Assignment: History Debate

Create a TV-style discussion on a historical topic or event, highlighting different views about it.

image

Suggested techniques 

You could do this by having an expert representing one point of view being interviewed, or as a panel discussion representing many different opinions.

This can be done purely as a modern studio debate, or could involve historical figures (e.g. a discussion with an early 20th century scientist on whether eugenics are justified).

Intersperse the presentation with still images and video if appropriate.

For teachers: benefits to students

  • This is good for moral arguments, particularly those where historical attitudes conflict strongly with modern attitudes, as it enables the students to put themselves into that historical context.
  • This can be done as a group project where the students have to reflect different points of view. If done as a solo project, the student will demonstrate that they can appreciate all sides of the issue and can present the different arguments and views clearly and accurately.
  • Adding multimedia content enables the student to approach the subject in a richer way than just using written text and still images.
  • Finding images and music to enhance the presentation requires detailed research.
  • Providing narration builds confidence in speaking without needing to do it in front of an audience or camera.
  • Creating a multimedia presentation helps develop presentational skills and requires the student to consider what information is best presented using the different media: spoken, written, or visual.

Suitability

  • Ages 14+
  • Suitable for groups
  • History

Downloadable resources

Two debate templates. The first a T.V chatshow style set including characters themed on the subject of history. The second, 4 characters standing at lecterns with a studio style backdrop and a video screen. Can be customized to suit a debate of any topic.

Click the link to download a Moviestorm movie template.

cloud.moviestorm.co.uk/Lesson_Plans/The%20History%20Debate.zip

FIle size: 544KB

cloud.moviestorm.co.uk/Lesson_Plans/Debate.zip

File size: 412KB

 

Installation instructions

Download the file and extract the zip folder to this location: 

  • Vista, Windows 7, Macs: [Username]/Moviestorm/Movies 
  • Windows XP: C:/Documents and Settings/[Username]/Moviestorm/Movies

Permission is granted to download, copy, and redistribute this page.

More lesson ideas